Each summer, the staff & students of the University of Louisville Interfaith Center host milkshake nights during the orientation sessions for incoming freshmen. Their "SOS-ers" bring them by and we play music, games, make a whole bunch of delicious milkshakes for free, and ask them to fill out short info cards, which are entered into a drawing for various prizes to be given out at the beginning of the Fall semester.
The info cards ask for basic contact info, and then asks the student to rank the importance of spirituality in their life on a scale of 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). We then list 8 denominational/faith identities and ask them to indicate their preference. The categories (based on the groups renting space from the Interfaith Center) are: Episcopalian, Jewish, Methodist, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Catholic. We also list "other" with a blank for filling in other options. A couple of years ago we added the 8th category: "Spiritual but Not Religious" (SBnR).
As a city, Louisville is largely Roman Catholic & Southern Baptist. We're also home to a very large 'non-denominational' megachurch, so those categories are always the largest. Those choosing SbNR, however, have become very large in the years since we added that option, easily rivaling those traditional identities.
Tonight was session 2 of orientation and I'm always eager to get the names of Episcopalians who have landed on campus, so I started going through the cards. I also decided to get a jump start on the profile of the incoming class. (Thanks to new alum Will for helping me out!)
Here we are after Session 2 (total of 229):
Religious Preference:
[these groups are listed by name]
Episcopalian: 2 (.9%)
Jewish: 0 (0)
Methodist: 11 (5%)
Lutheran: 2 (.9%)
Presbyterian: 5 (2%)
SbNR: 14 (6%)
Catholic: 108 (47%)
[these are the write ins]
Other (no other info): 3 (1%)
Other (Atheism): 3 (1%)
Other (UCC): 1 (.4%)
Other (Baptist): 32 (14%)
Other (Non-Denom): 4 (1.7%)
Other (Christian): 11 (5%)
Other (Agnostic): 2 (.9%)
Other (Christianity): 1 (.4%)
Other (Not Religious): 1 (.4%)
Other (Jedi): 1 (.4%)
Other (Sthn. Baptist): 1 (.4%)
Other (Protestant): 3 (1%)
Other (Pentacostal): 1 (.4%)
Other (Catholic-ish): 1 (.4%)
Other (UU): 1 (.4%)
Other (openly Christian): 1 (.4%)
Other (Disciples of Christ): 2 (1%)
Other (Church of Christ): 1 (.4%)
Other (Church of God): 1 (.4%)
Other (Dark Romanticist Christian): 1 (.4%)
N/A: 1 (.4%)
(No indication): 14 (6%)
Level of Importance:
Avg: 3.7
0: 7 (3%)
1: 10 (4%)
2: 16 (7%)
3: 57 (25%)
4: 62 (27%)
5: 73 (32%)
(4 people added in more precise levels: 3.5: 3 (1%); 4.5: 1 (.4%))
So what?
Well, maybe nothing. But if the SBnR number stays that low, it would be a significant shift downward. As the sample grows over the summer, we'll see what the numbers bear out. It's very possible it's skewed by the demographics of who attends the early sessions. Students get to request (by preference) which orientation sessions to attend, and Honor students get to choose first. In Louisville, our Catholic high schools produce high-achieving students, so the staff is guessing we've seen proportionally a few more Catholics in the initial sessions than we will during the rest of the summer. Of course, lots of factors could produce a correlation between high institutional academic achievement and religious preference. We'll keep watching it!
Also, the person who wrote "ish" next to Catholic is my favorite so far. "Jedi" is too easy. We usually get a few clever students who turn in entertaining cards each year, which, being church geeks, we greatly enjoy.